Deport Illegals to Reduce Inequality

California Gov. Gavin Newsom recently pointed out the problems with mass immigration. Just don’t expect him to realize it.

In late June, Newsom came out in support of a national billionaires’ tax. In contrast, he’s opposed to the billionaires’ tax that will be on the California ballot this year. Set aside the political implications of this move and think about the problem Newsom claims to be trying to solve.

“Record corporate profits flowed into stock buybacks and executive compensation,” he wrote. “Workers’ real wages stagnated, and vibrant middle-class communities were hollowed out. It is time to stop pretending otherwise.”

What’s remarkable is how closely these complaints mimic the objections President Donald Trump has raised about immigration.

While conservatives aren’t categorically opposed to corporate profits, not all profit is praiseworthy. In his 1850 classic book “The Law,” French economist Frederic Bastiat warned against “the fatal tendency that exists in the heart of man to satisfy his wants with the least possible effort.” He calls this plunder and warns that the government can be turned into a vehicle for “legal plunder.” Some examples include direct subsidies to private companies. Regulations and mandates frequently benefit some people over others.

Immigration is another example of a government policy that can artificially boost corporate profits. An influx of immigrant workers — both legal and illegal — increases the supply of labor. An increase in supply reduces prices or, in this case, wages. If America only admitted doctors, surgeons, dentists, lawyers and engineers, this could benefit low- and middle-income Americans. A greater supply of physicians could reduce the cost of health care.

But that hasn’t been happening. Legal immigration is largely based on family considerations. The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program is based on location. Assuming they intend to work and not just sit on welfare, illegal immigrants are usually low-skilled. The H-1B visa program is supposed to attract skilled immigrants. Instead, many companies have abused the program to import cheaper labor.

The result is that mass immigration has put downward pressure on wages for low- and middle-income Americans. But this has been great for many corporate executives. Immigration has allowed them to reduce their labor costs, which has helped boost corporate profits — the exact thing Newsom objects to.

Newsom isn’t pointing out a new problem. He’s repackaging what Trump has been saying for a decade.

“Protecting our workers also means reforming our system of legal immigration,” Trump said in a February 2017 address to Congress. “The current, outdated system depresses wages for our poorest workers.”

“Our current immigration system works at cross-purposes, placing downward pressure on wages for the working class,” Trump said in a 2019 speech.

“Some employers, using practices now widely adopted by entire sectors, have abused the H-1B statute and its regulations to artificially suppress wages, resulting in a disadvantageous labor market for American citizens,” Trump wrote in a September proclamation that put new restrictions on the H-1B visa program.

Ironically, Newsom’s office criticized Trump’s actions to restrict H-1B visas.

Trump has also pointed out that influxes of immigrants have swamped communities around the country. Whether or not they were eating the dogs, he was right that Haitian immigrants overwhelmed Springfield, Ohio. Even larger cities, like Chicago, New York and Denver, struggled to deal with the Biden-era influx.

Newsom’s proposed wealth tax wouldn’t fix the problems he’s identified. Just look at Europe. Over the decades, many European countries passed wealth taxes. Most of them have now repealed them. They found wealth taxes generated little tax money and were hard to administer.

If Newsom wants to reduce inequality, not just pander to the socialists seeking to control the Democrat Party, he should support Trump’s efforts to reduce immigration.

Agree/Disagree with the author(s)? Let them know in the comments below and be heard by 10’s of thousands of CDN readers each day!