Judge Refuses to Halt the Shift of SAVE Student Loan Borrowers Into New Plans With Higher Payments

A federal judge has refused to stop the Education Department from moving borrowers out of the defunct SAVE student loan plan, a shift that could push some monthly bills from SAVE’s median of about $110 to several hundred dollars.

U.S. District Judge Loren L. AliKhan in Washington, D.C., denied a preliminary injunction and stay Wednesday in a suit by four borrowers, ruling that they had not shown they would suffer irreparable harm without court intervention.

The borrowers argued that when a Missouri federal court vacated the SAVE rule in March, an older plan known as REPAYE was automatically revived, and that the department was “shadow repealing” it, Bloomberg Law reported.

AliKhan found the harms the borrowers described amounted to “modest increases in monthly payments and unspecified lost interest subsidies,” and said their months-long delay in seeking relief cut against their claims.

The sums at issue were small. One plaintiff said her payment would rise $14 a month and another put his increase at $49, according to the opinion.

She also ruled two plaintiffs lacked standing to challenge taxes on their loan forgiveness. A temporary federal tax break for forgiven student debt expired Dec. 31, 2025, making discharges after that date taxable income.

The case is not over. AliKhan said she would rule on the department’s motion to dismiss “in due course,” and the decision did not settle whether REPAYE legally came back, The College Investor noted.

What It Means for Borrowers

The ruling lets the department keep pushing SAVE enrollees into other plans. It announced in March that SAVE enrollees must switch plans and began sending 90-day notices in July. Those who do not choose will be moved, generally into a standard plan.

About 7.5 million borrowers were in SAVE in March, and the department says more than 2 million have picked a new plan, suggesting roughly 5.5 million are still holding out, Money reported.

The median monthly payment under SAVE was $110, compared with $674 for a typical standard-plan bill, Money reported.

Borrowers can instead choose an income-driven option, including the new Repayment Assistance Plan created by last year’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act or Income-Based Repayment. Older PAYE and ICR plans end June 30, 2028.

Interest has been building on SAVE balances since Aug. 1, 2025, and months spent in the SAVE forbearance do not count toward income-driven forgiveness or Public Service Loan Forgiveness, Money reported.

Scott Buchanan, executive director of the Student Loan Servicing Alliance, told Money that holdouts should not expect the forbearance to last. “I’m pretty sure you’re going to get a bill in short order,” he said.

The department urged borrowers who have not switched to take “immediate action,” an official told the outlet.

Content created by Conservative Daily News and some content syndicated through CDN is available for re-publication without charge under the Creative Commons license. Visit our syndication page for details and requirements.

Carl Fox

Carl Fox is the senior money and finance writer for Conservative Daily News. Follow him in the "Money & The Economy" section at CDN and see his posts on the "Junior Economists" Facebook page.

Share
Published by
Carl Fox

Recent Posts

Intuit Sells Mailchimp for $3.68 Billion, Less Than a Third of What It Paid, as Its Stock Tumbles

Intuit agreed to sell Mailchimp to Italy's Bending Spoons and cut its revenue outlook on…

13 minutes ago

Nasdaq Futures Slide as Asia Heads for Its Worst Week Since 2020 and the AI Selloff Spreads Worldwide

Nasdaq-100 futures fell about 1.4% Friday after Tokyo and Seoul each dropped more than 5%,…

13 minutes ago

Bon Appétit

Democrats ran on affordability, then ditched it right after the election to pursue their radical…

14 minutes ago

Cyber Director Cairncross Pushed Out Over His Credentials, Officials Say, as Pentagon Tech Chief Kirsten Davies Takes Over

Pentagon chief information officer Kirsten Davies is stepping in as national cyber director after Sean…

30 minutes ago

Commerce OK’d Nearly 880,000 Nvidia and AMD AI Chips for China, Including Military-Linked Firms, House Panel Reveals

Documents released by the House Foreign Affairs Committee show the Commerce Department approved 879,868 advanced…

54 minutes ago

Senate Passes Permitting Overhaul 62-33, Aiming to Speed Energy Projects and Shield Ratepayers From Data Center Costs

The Senate passed a sweeping bipartisan bill to speed approvals for power plants, transmission lines…

50 minutes ago