Privatizing Social Security Is Not the Answer

I have written a couple of recent columns in which I discussed more than a few possible reforms that could be made to Social Security that would keep the program solvent for generations to come. A couple of readers wrote to ask me why I didn’t include plans to privatize the system as a way to fix Social Security. The reason I didn’t include such plans is that they don’t work. I’ve discussed this issue many times in the past. But I guess it’s time to clarify things once again.

Plans to privatize Social Security usually involve one of two scenarios. One form of “privatizing” Social Security has to do with how the fund’s assets are invested. Some claim that Social Security should be managed more like other public pension funds. Most of those funds have a diversified portfolio, with a variety of investments. But every nickel of Social Security assets is invested, by law, in U.S. Treasury notes, considered by everyone the safest of all places to stash your cash. What most folks who advocate putting Social Security funds into private markets can’t comprehend is the immense size of the Social Security trust funds. Compared to large public pension funds (like many teachers’ retirement funds or police and firefighter funds), Social Security is like Fort Knox and these public funds are just big piggy banks. Those funds may have millions or even billions of dollars in assets. But Social Security has trillions. That’s a big difference. You simply can’t compare them.

Or put it another way. Social Security makes up about one-fourth of the entire federal budget of the United States. You just don’t take a quarter of our country’s budget and put it on Wall Street. After all, would you want the federal government, via the Social Security trust fund, to be the major owner of Meta stock or the primary investor in Philip Morris?

Another approach to “privatizing” Social Security would allow individual taxpayers to use private or managed accounts to supplement future Social Security benefits. And when you hear talk of such proposals, you must remember to ask this question: Is it a “carve out” plan or an “add-on” plan? There is a huge difference. One possibly could work. The other could not. But neither plan would do anything to solve Social Security’s current funding crunch. I will explain.

Both plans involve requiring younger workers to contribute money to an IRA-type account that would offer several investment options. The worker could choose a safe but generally low-yielding account or a riskier but potentially more rewarding one. The investments from this account would then be used to augment Social Security retirement benefits.

But the difference lies in the funding details. In a carve-out plan (these are usually the plans touted by Republicans), the worker’s IRA investment would be funded with a portion of his or her Social Security payroll tax. For example, currently 6.2% of a worker’s salary is deducted for Social Security taxes. A carve-out plan might specify that 4.2% continue to be used to fund Social Security, while 2% would be funneled into the private account. In other words, this plan gets its funding by carving it out of the current Social Security system.

On the other hand, an “add-on” plan (the plans usually touted by Democrats) would require a worker to contribute an extra amount to fund the private account investments. So, 6.2% of his or her salary would still be deducted to finance Social Security benefits. But in addition, that worker would be required to chip in an extra percentage point or two of salary to fund the Social Security supplement. So this plan gets its funding by adding on to the current Social Security system.

Each plan has its pluses and minuses. The downside to an add-on plan is that more out-of-paycheck spending would be required from workers to fund their retirement portfolio. But the advantage to the plan is its greater rewards. Most “add-on” proposals are modeled after the highly successful “Thrift Savings Plan,” an add-on IRA that has been available to federal government workers for years and has given many of them the kind of financial security in retirement not usually associated with middle-class civil servants.

The upside to “carve out” proposals is that no extra financial burden would be placed on young workers to finance the supplemental benefits. But the often unexplained downside is that huge reductions would be necessary in future Social Security benefits. It’s just simple math. If you are going to carve out about one-third of the Social Security payroll tax to fund a worker’s private supplement, then obviously future Social Security benefits for that same worker are going to have to be cut by at least one-third.

But carve-out advocates always say they won’t cut benefits. And that leads to impossible transition costs. Remember: Social Security is a “pay-as-you-go” program, meaning the money deducted from today’s workers’ paychecks is used to fund benefits to current retirees. So, if you cut the amount of money going into the system and say you will not cut benefits, you must somehow come up with the funds to pay those promised benefits to current and future retirees. And if taxes aren’t raised to cover those costs, experts estimate the transition costs would add trillions of dollars to the federal debt. (That’s what sunk former President George W. Bush’s carve-out privatization plan in the early 2000s.)

But here is the most important point I need to make about proposals for private accounts — whether carve-out or add-on. Although they are often mentioned in the same breath as other proposals to “save Social Security,” they do nothing of the sort. Social Security’s long-range financing problems are the result of baby boomers turning into senior boomers. For years, Social Security has been working extremely well with a ratio of three workers supporting one retiree. But by the time all the boomers retire, there will be only two workers supporting each retiree. The system simply cannot work as it’s currently structured at a two-to-one ratio.

As I’ve recently pointed out to my readers, there are many relatively modest proposals for reform that will keep the system running for many more generations. All of those possible solutions involve either slight tax increases or moderate cuts in benefits. None of them involve the creation of private accounts for Social Security beneficiaries. I am not saying the private accounts are a bad idea. I am saying that they have nothing to do with the future financial health of the program.

Agree/Disagree with the author(s)? Let them know in the comments below and be heard by 10’s of thousands of CDN readers each day!

Tom Margenau

Tom Margenau worked for 32 years at the Social Security Administration, including as director of its public information office and as deputy press officer, before retiring in 2005. He has written the nationally syndicated "Social Security and You" column since 1997.

Share
Published by
Tom Margenau

Recent Posts

Pittsburgh’s Moon Shot

PITTSBURGH -- The photographs hang near the front of the building, and John Thornton walks…

13 minutes ago

Donald Trump Is Making Harvard and Yale Rich

Well, the rich really are getting richer — at least when it comes to higher…

15 minutes ago

Nvidia Posts a $115.8 Billion Quarter, but Its Board Says Jensen Huang Is Not Coming Back

Nvidia beat Wall Street forecasts in its first report since Jensen Huang resigned as CEO,…

3 hours ago

U.S. Jets Strike Iran’s Qeshm Island After a Third Iranian Drone Attack on Bahrain in Five Days

American fighter jets hit a Revolutionary Guard missile site on Qeshm Island after Iranian drones…

3 hours ago

Trump Shrugs Off the Outages as ‘Life,’ but Hawley Says It Can’t All Be ‘Happenstance’

President Trump says a week of outages at airlines, banks and the NSA is “fine,”…

3 hours ago

Apple Says Internal Update Caused Outages Hitting iCloud, Apple Pay and the App Store

Apple said Tuesday that many of its systems were back online after an internal update…

6 hours ago