Science, Technology, and Social Media

Elon Musk’s X Asks Supreme Court To Weigh In On Jack Smith’s Trump Search Warrant

Special Counsel Jack Smith’s battle with X, formerly Twitter, over a warrant for former President Donald Trump’s account reached the Supreme Court Tuesday.

U.S. District Court Judge for the District of Columbia Beryl Howell granted Smith’s request for a warrant in January 2023, along with a nondisclosure order prohibiting X from notifying anyone of the warrant’s existence. This allowed Smith access to data like draft tweets and direct messages as part of his investigation into Trump’s actions around Jan. 6.

The company argues that the precedent set by lower court rulings on the issue has “far-reaching” implications, allowing the government to “invade other privileges,” such as attorney-client or journalist-source, by “seeking communications from, and gagging, third parties.”

X’s delay in compliance while it fought the order on First Amendment grounds earned it a $350,000 sanction, which a three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld.

“In an unprecedented end-run around executive privilege, Special Counsel Jack Smith obtained a nondisclosure order preventing Twitter from notifying former President Trump of a warrant for private communications that he sent and received during his presidency,” X’s petition states. “The courts below rejected Twitter’s First Amendment challenge to the nondisclosure order after ordering Twitter to produce the communications without affording the former President an opportunity to assert privilege over them.”

X asked the justices in its petition to consider whether electronic communications services providers can be forced to turn over potentially privileged communications while there is a pending First Amendment challenge to an order that prevents the company from notifying the user.

It also asked whether “the First Amendment permits gagging a provider in a highly public investigation where the government does not (a) demonstrate that disclosure would jeopardize the investigation’s integrity; or (b) disprove the workability of a less-restrictive alternative.”

The D.C. Circuit declined in January to reconsider the issue before the full court. However, four judges criticized their colleagues for failing to provide Trump a chance to invoke executive privilege by approving the request for a nondisclosure order.

“The Special Counsel’s approach obscured and bypassed any assertion of executive privilege and dodged the careful balance Congress struck in the Presidential Records Act,” Judge Naomi Rao, a Trump appointee, wrote in a statement at the time.

X argued in its petition that this case is “an ideal vehicle to resolve these significant and recurring issues.”

“The opinion below will radically alter the constitutional landscape, ‘declar[ing] open season on’ privileged records as long as the government can find them on a Twitter (or Microsoft, Google, or Amazon) server,” X argued.

Content created by The Daily Caller News Foundation is available without charge to any eligible news publisher that can provide a large audience. For licensing opportunities of our original content, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org

Katelynn Richardson

Share
Published by
Katelynn Richardson

Recent Posts

Israel Not Interested In Peace Talks With Iran, Netanyahu Says

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told ABC on Monday that Israel is not interested in…

6 hours ago

Acting US Attorney Shares Chilling Details Surrounding Assassination In Minnesota

Acting U.S. Attorney Joseph Thompson on Monday detailed the “chilling” background surrounding the fatal shootings…

6 hours ago

Pro-Palestine Libs Try Marching To Gaza, Run Into Trouble When Egyptians Beat The Hell Out Of Them

Egyptian authorities took dozens of anti-Israel activists into custody this past Thursday after thwarting a…

6 hours ago

Foreign Graduates Are Crushing Natural-Born Americans In Pay, Analysis Finds

College graduates who immigrated to the U.S. on student visas earn substantially more than their…

6 hours ago

Most Hispanic Voters Back Trump Deportation Policy Amid Anti-ICE Riots, Poll Shows

A majority of Hispanic voters back core elements of the Trump administration’s deportation policy according…

6 hours ago

Randi Weingarten Quits DNC

A teachers union boss synonymous with prolonged school closures during the COVID-19 pandemic has announced…

6 hours ago