French President Emmanuel Macron and British Prime Minister Keir Starmer announced this week that their countries would unilaterally recognize a Palestinian state.
The first problem with that is “Palestine” is a fictional place. There never was any such thing.
And diplomatic recognition of it no more changes this reality than if Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu were to decide to recognize the archipelago of Islamic banlieues on the outskirts of Paris as an independent nation.
But what exactly are Britain and France recognizing?
Mahmoud Abbas, the dictator of the Palestinian Authority in the “West Bank,” is now 89 years old. What does Macron and Starmer think will happen when he finally dies?
The best-case scenario, I suppose, is for another corrupt strongman to take over an independent “Palestine.” Will these Western European leaders back an autocracy?
What happens when a civil war breaks out? Because the prospects are quite high. Since the Oslo Accords, the Palestinian Authority has relied heavily on Israel’s security apparatus to stay in power. It would almost certainly implode without it.
The French and Brits should recall that the first thing Palestinians did when handed a protostate in 2005 was destroy over 3,000 greenhouses and modern farming systems that American Jews had purchased for $14 million and handed them, gratis.
The second thing they did, though, was put Hamas in charge.
So, will France and Britain support open elections in this new nation? What if Hamas, or some other iteration of that organization, wins those elections? Will France and Britain recognize such a state?
“Hamas does not represent the Palestinian people,” Macron claimed during a visit to Ramallah with Abbas in 2023. This is Western elitist twaddle: The unpleasant truth is that Islamists far better represent the people than the “moderate” Fatah party, which is propped up with billions of Western dollars and Israeli assistance.
In 2006, Hamas not only won the Gaza elections, but it also won a majority of the parliamentary seats in the PA, which it still holds. In 2024, Hamas and Fatah signed the Beijing Declaration, brokered by Communist China, agreeing to form an “interim national reconciliation government.”
Will the French and British “recognize” a similar arrangement in the future? Is Macron going to send French troops into Jenin to root out Islamist militants firing Iranian- or Qatari-funded missiles into Jerusalem?
Whether the French could even win such a war, I suppose, is the better question.
And what will “Palestine” look like? Not once in the dozens of attempts to give Palestinians a state have they accepted any arrangement that didn’t include “a right to return” into Israel proper.
“Nakba” itself — Palestinians’ bitter term for what they see as the “catastrophe” of Israel’s founding — was the result of a war that was launched by local Arabs and their allies who rejected a state.
Even if a deal could be struck, what makes Macron and Starmer believe Palestinians can run their own nation, anyway? Palestinians in Gaza are unwilling to build the basic infrastructure necessary for themselves. despite receiving hundreds of millions in yearly aid.
Every Israeli restriction on Palestinians in Gaza has been put in place to mitigate violence. When you send Gaza concrete, they build tunnels and military installations under hospitals, not schools or businesses. If you build them infrastructure, they dig up water pipes to make casements for rockets. When you allow shipments of necessities, they smuggle in explosives. When you send food, they give it to the terrorist army before the children.
Unless, of course, those children have been recruited to the Islamist cause.
Will France and Britain send in their citizens to administer this new state and its borders to ensure that the same doesn’t happen again? Or will Israel just be forced to invade once more?
Now, of course, Macron says Hamas must be “disarmed” and that Gaza needs to be rebuilt. But the French and British recognition of “Palestine” incentivizes the opposite. What does he think Israel has been trying to do?
Is France or Britain going to disarm Hamas? Is France or Britain going to bring back the more than 50 hostages still being held and tortured in Gaza?
Macron and Starmer, like so many apologists for Palestinian violence, lose nothing with this cynical moral preening to their domestic Islamists.
The real world is a lot more complicated.
Agree/Disagree with the author(s)? Let them know in the comments below and be heard by 10’s of thousands of CDN readers each day!
There never was a Palestinian state. The Romans renamed Judea (the ancestral home of all Jews) , Palestine (Palestina to be exact), after they kicked the Jews out of Jerusalem that had been their home for thousands of years since the beginning of recorded history. Since then, the name of Palestine appeared as an area on maps because it changed hands so many times and was simply a generic term for a place on map that changed hands constantly. The area of Palestine was occupied variously after the Romans by several muslim caliphates, the Crusaders, the Ottoman Empire and finally by the British, before Israel became a nation. Egypt claimed the area known as the Gaza Strip and Jordan claimed the West Bank when Israel was created as a state in 1948 by the United Nations after the Holocaust and World War II. Israel took Gaza and the West Bank from Egypt and Jordan after they were attacked by Egypt, Jordan, and Syria in 1967 in what is known as “the six day war”. “Palestinians” is simply the relatively new invented name of Arabs from various states that resided with Jews in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank after the war.
But perhaps the biggest lie is that establishing a Palestinian state would solve the problem. When President Clinton tried to broker a deal at Camp David in 2000 for the Israelis to give up the Gaza Strip and 97% of the West Bank to the Palestinians to form a Palestinian state it failed. It failed because Yasser Arafat (the head of the PLO at the time) refused the deal. And that was before the PLO was controlled by Hamas. Nevertheless in an effort to create peace, the Israelis ceded the Gaza Strip to the Palestinians in 2005 and removed all of their military and forcibly removed 23 of their own settlements. Instead of building their own state, In 2006 the Palestinians themselves ELECTED Hamas to be in control of the Gaza Strip. Their charter calls for the complete destruction of Israel and they have been building tunnels and attacking Israel ever since. So there never was a Palestinian state, Israel gave them their “state” in 2005 where they have been attacking Israel ever since. Israel, has since its inception, only wanted peace and only fought and attacked those who attack her first and have openly sworn to destroy them. As on Oct. 7, when Hamas and “Palestinians” from Gaza entered Israel and brutally massacred over 1200 innocent Israelis and are still keeping and torturing innocent hostages.