GOP Health Care Bill Analyzed H.R. 3400
Sep 27th, 2009 | By Rich Mitchell | Category: Featured, Health Care ReformAs recently as last week, congressional liberals have been saying that republicans don’t have any ideas and therefor have not put any health care legislation on the table. Well, before the August recess, a bill was introduced in the house and is certainly a GOP-sponsored health care reform bill. While far-from-perfect, it is perhaps the best chance at health care reform out of the three major bills circulating in congress.
So while Nancy Pelosi fights to keep this and the other 33+ that have been submitted by conservatives out of the public light by preventing floor or committee votes, we’ll dig-in and see what they have to offer.
As the bill gets amended, I’ll update this post, but to start, here’s a short, to-the-point summary of 3400.
The bill seems to have several key objectives:
- Decrease Costs to Consumers
- Increase Competition at both the insurance and point-of-care levels
- HSAs are explicitly listed as acceptable coverage
- See “Increase Transparency”
- There are no tax-levying provisions in the bill (no new taxes)
- Tax credits are given for carrying coverage for those that may need assistance to pay
- Still allows for the excise tax that has existed since 1986 on employers that offer no coverage
- Tort reform
- no limit on economic damages
- $250,000 limit on non-economic damages
- Increase Competition at both the insurance and point-of-care levels
- Increase Portability
- Move ownership of coverage to the individual
- Creates Individual Membership Associations : I believe this is a way to group individuals together to create a larger risk pool through an association-run exchange
- Allows deductions for premiums paid to individual plans (similar to group plans through employers)
- Increase Acesss
- Eliminate coverage limits (no lifetime maximum)
- Provide coverage for pre-existing conditions
- Increase Transparency
- State Transparency Portals that will list quality statistics for hospitals, doctors and facilities as well as their pricing
- Increase Quality
- Institutes performance-based quality measures
- State transparency portals
- Targeted fund to support Student loans for medical students
- Loan forgiveness for primary care providers (family doctors)
- Tracking banned providers across state-lines (fraud and abuse prevention)
- Explicitly eliminate funding for abortions except in cases of danger to the mother or rape/incest
- No government intervention into health care benefits
- No public or government run options of any kind
- Medicare and Medicaid benefits are not altered
- No new beuarocracies
Check out the full text of H.R. 3400 [here] and comment below with what you see (good or bad).
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
Related posts:
- CDN Predictions for Post-Health Care Reform America No long narative, just the basic predictions: Health Care Premiums will rise at a faster...
- Analysis of Republican Health Care Reform Bill On November 3rd, the GOP made it’s new health care reform bill available for review. ...
- Democrats Merge 3 House Bills: Pelosi-care On the March Fox news reported that the new House Bill will be formally announced tomorrow morning. The...
- Conservatives Losing Heart? New Poll Shows Increasing Support for ObamaCare In a Rasmussen opinion poll released today, the latest figures show that support for the...
- Health Care Reform Does Not Increase Competition For months we have been fed several mis-truths, myths, and outright lies about health care....
- Health Care Reform Analyzed: A Critical View of H.R.3200 Health care reform is badly-needed, but I am certain that what is being proposed won’t...




Thanks for a good report on this bill. I tried to vote in the poll, but got an error whenever I tried to select HR 3400.